Vivaldi: L'Estro Armonico (豆瓣)

表演者: Fabio Biondi, Europa Galante
流派: 古典
专辑类型: CD
介质: Audio CD
发行时间: July 14, 1998
出版者: Virgin Classics
唱片数: 2
条形码: 0724354531521

豆瓣评分

8.7

45人评价

5星

46.7%
4星

46.7%
3星

6.7%
2星

0.0%
1星

0.0%

想听在听听过

评价:

简介 · · · · · ·

　　Fabio Biondi领衔Europa Galante（华丽欧洲）古乐团演绎Vivaldi的协奏曲集第三号和声的灵感。这个版本见仁见智，喜欢的会喜欢得不得了，讨厌的也会非常极端。因为Fabio的摇滚化演绎对作品作了诸多处理，他希望表现出一个生前作为另类人物的Vivaldi。可以肯定的是，对于初听古典的人，Fabio的版本极具诱惑力，而资深人士可能会选择更加稳妥的版本。
　　Amazon.com上两位顾客的评价就是典型：
　　反对者：
　　Reviewer: A music fan
　　I had 3 excellent versions of Vivaldi's opus 3 (I Solisti Veneti, I Musici and N. Marriner), but I wanted a new ... (展开全部) 　　Fabio Biondi领衔Europa Galante（华丽欧洲）古乐团演绎Vivaldi的协奏曲集第三号和声的灵感。这个版本见仁见智，喜欢的会喜欢得不得了，讨厌的也会非常极端。因为Fabio的摇滚化演绎对作品作了诸多处理，他希望表现出一个生前作为另类人物的Vivaldi。可以肯定的是，对于初听古典的人，Fabio的版本极具诱惑力，而资深人士可能会选择更加稳妥的版本。
　　Amazon.com上两位顾客的评价就是典型：
　　反对者：
　　Reviewer: A music fan
　　I had 3 excellent versions of Vivaldi's opus 3 (I Solisti Veneti, I Musici and N. Marriner), but I wanted a new version to enjoy it with real DDD sound. Unfortunately, I'm very dissapointed by this CD. Although I have listened it many times to see if can get used to it, I cannot like this performance. Europa Galante is an excellent ensemble, but in my opinion the problem here was the conductor.
　　
　　Apparently Biondi tried to be "original" at any cost, so in each concerto he needs to add some fancy "effects" as he thought this music needs to be made more interesting. As a result you hear a sharp attack of the notes in one bar, the next bar is played legato, the following bar is with dotted notes, now the next bar is pianissimo,and now the following is fortissimo and so on... There is never a steady moment where the music can expand and you can feel the Harmony. You are just shaken around. The dynamics is exaggerated (huge and senseless dynamic jumps), the duration of some silences is exaggerated, he adds some annoying ritardandos that destroy the natural progression of the melodic line, etc. In addition, there are a lot of unnecessary 'embellishment' notes, much beyond what the music can stand.
　　
　　This concertos contains very beautiful slow tempos that are treated here without respect. In some of them the chords are played so forte that it sounds as if someone were slashing the violins, destroying the subtle atmosphere of the music; in others, the soloist insists with his melismatic ornamental notes that trivializes the music up to a point of making it sound almost vulgar. I recognize that there are some good movements and the continuo part is very good, but I had a hard time for most of this disc because of the hyperkinetic and frantic style. For some moments I felt so annoyed that if this had been a live performance I would have tempted to stand up and shout: Could you please just play it how it was written! This CD will not show you L'Estro Armonico as Vivaldi deserves. It seems as if the soloist is much more interested in just showing of his fingering dexterity, no matter how much damage to the music is done. Finally I gave away this CD and purchased the version by C. Hogwood. That one was definitely better.
　　
　　支持者：
　　 Interesting introduction to Opus 3, October 29, 2003
　　Reviewer: "andrewjs0281" (Brooklyn, NY United States) - See all my reviews
　　Having never heard this set of concerti or anything by this orchestra/leader, I was satisifed for the most part. Vivaldi keeps you guessing quite often with where the music is going, always delivers a melodic, exciting and rhythmic force, and keeps you aware that he's making the players work hard and (ideally) feel something in the music.
　　The only reservation I have about this recording is that Biondi's intepretation(s) do take liberties at times. Sometimes the music is a bit too snappy/sleek (at least for what I look for in Vivaldi), (E.G. the #7 for 4 Violins), and one wishes for a little more passion. At other times the music seems a bit too dance-like, especially in the #6 Concerto for Solo Violin.
　　
　　Some of the reviewers have expressed distate for Biondi's liberties, other have found them refreshing. This is my first approach to this set of music and the performers, so I'll just say that you can't go wrong with this CD. Biondi is definitely making the music his own, it's up to the listener is they enjoy that.
　　
　　
　　曲目信息：
　　
　　L'estro armonico, concertos (12) for 1-4 solo instruments, strings & continuo, Op. 3 Concerto No. 2 in G minor, RV578
　　Composed by Antonio Vivaldi
　　with Fabio Biondi, Europa Galante
　　
　　
　　L'estro armonico, concertos (12) for 1-4 solo instruments, strings & continuo, Op. 3 Concerto No. 1 in D major, R549
　　Composed by Antonio Vivaldi
　　with Fabio Biondi, Europa Galante
　　
　　
　　L'estro armonico, concertos (12) for 1-4 solo instruments, strings & continuo, Op. 3 Concerto No. 6 in A minor, RV356
　　Composed by Antonio Vivaldi
　　with Fabio Biondi, Europa Galante
　　
　　
　　L'estro armonico, concertos (12) for 1-4 solo instruments, strings & continuo, Op. 3 Concerto No. 5 in A major, RV519
　　Composed by Antonio Vivaldi
　　with Fabio Biondi, Europa Galante
　　
　　
　　L'estro armonico, concertos (12) for 1-4 solo instruments, strings & continuo, Op. 3 Concerto No. 4 in E minor, RV550
　　Composed by Antonio Vivaldi
　　with Fabio Biondi, Europa Galante
　　
　　
　　L'estro armonico, concertos (12) for 1-4 solo instruments, strings & continuo, Op. 3 Concerto No. 3 in G major, RV310
　　Composed by Antonio Vivaldi
　　with Fabio Biondi, Europa Galante
　　
　　
　　L'estro armonico, concertos (12) for 1-4 solo instruments, strings & continuo, Op. 3 Concerto No. 8 in A minor, RV522
　　Composed by Antonio Vivaldi
　　with Fabio Biondi, Europa Galante
　　
　　
　　L'estro armonico, concertos (12) for 1-4 solo instruments, strings & continuo, Op. 3 Concerto No. 7 in F major, RV567
　　Composed by Antonio Vivaldi
　　with Fabio Biondi, Europa Galante
　　
　　
　　L'estro armonico, concertos (12) for 1-4 solo instruments, strings & continuo, Op. 3 Concerto No. 11 in D minor, RV565
　　Composed by Antonio Vivaldi
　　with Fabio Biondi, Europa Galante
　　
　　
　　L'estro armonico, concertos (12) for 1-4 solo instruments, strings & continuo, Op. 3 Concerto No. 9 in D major, RV230
　　Composed by Antonio Vivaldi
　　with Fabio Biondi, Europa Galante
　　
　　
　　L'estro armonico, concertos (12) for 1-4 solo instruments, strings & continuo, Op. 3 Concerto No. 10 in B minor, RV580
　　Composed by Antonio Vivaldi
　　with Fabio Biondi, Europa Galante
　　
　　
　　L'estro armonico, concertos (12) for 1-4 solo instruments, strings & continuo, Op. 3 Concerto No. 12 in E major, RV265
　　Composed by Antonio Vivaldi
　　with Fabio Biondi, Europa Galante

曲目 · · · · · ·

Disc: 1
1. Concerto No.2 In G Minor: 1. Adagio e Spiccato
2. Concerto No.2 In G Minor: 2. Allegro
3. Concerto No.2 In G Minor: 3. Larghetto
4. Concerto No.2 In G Minor: 4. Allegro
5. Concerto No.1 in D major: 1. Allegro
6. Concerto No.1 in D major: 2. Largo e spiccato
7. Concerto No.1 in D major: 3. Allegro
8. Concerto No.6 In A Minor: 1. Allegro
9. Concerto No.6 In A Minor: 2. Largo
10. Concerto No.6 In A Minor: 3. Presto

Disc: 2
1. Concerto No.8 In A Minor, RV522: 1. Andante
2. Concerto No.8 In A Minor, RV522: 2. Larghetto e spiritoso
3. Concerto No.8 In A Minor, RV522: 3. Allegro
4. Concerto No.7 In F Major, RV567: 1. Andante
5. Concerto No.7 In F Major, RV567: 2. Adagio
6. Concerto No.7 In F Major, RV567: 3. Allegro
7. Concerto No.7 In F Major, RV567: 4. Adagio
8. Concerto No.7 In F Major, RV567: 5. Allegro
9. Concerto No. 11 In D Minor, RV565: 1. Allegro
10. Concerto No. 11 In D Minor, RV565: 2. Adagio e spiccato